The idea of a locked-room thriller with the jury in a big Hollywood trial really caught my eye. For me it sounded like the perfect read to curl up with on a rainy night. I did just that, so today I want to tell you all about this book and what I thought!
A big thank you to Netgalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for providing me with an eARC to read and review. This doesn’t affect my opinion in any way.
Everyone is Watching meets Twelve Angry Men in a tense and twisty locked-room thriller where, sequestered together until the Hollywood trial is closed, a jury must decide the fate of an actor accused of attempted murder, but this jury has explosive secrets, and one of them is about to get away with a murder of their own.
No one here is innocent.
Hollywood’s biggest movie star, Danny Scott, stands accused of trying to murder his wife, starlet Hope Harrison, in a case that has taken the world by storm. Everyone is What led to the events of that night, and what darker truths simmer beneath the surface of Danny and Hope’s marriage? As the world watches, twelve sequestered jurors must decide Danny’s fate. But even a jury has its secrets…
Juror 6 is risking everything for this trial. Even her life.
Juror 2 is playing games. But can he keep one step ahead of his own lies?
Juror 13, the alternate, will do anything to be on that jury. Anything.
Juror 7 is hardly noticed by anyone. Just as she planned.
As each juror vies for the verdict they want, secrets, obsessions, and plots for revenge will come to light in the stands. Because everyone is lying. Everyone is guilty. And one of them might be planning a murder of their own.
With shocking twists and propulsive pacing, This Jury Is Guilty is a thought-provoking, locked-room thriller exploring our obsessions with true crime, the blurry lines between fact and fiction, and the lengths we’re willing to go to seek justice. For fans of Amy Tintera, Steve Cavanagh, and Ellery Lloyd.
Review
This Jury Is Guilty started off really strong for me. I loved the little excerpts with the news, the pieces of the trial, and the multiple POVs from the members of our jury. I can only imagine how intense it is to be on a jury in such a high profile case. Especially when it seems all of our jury members have their own motive of why they want to be there.
I can’t talk about the details too much without spoiling this story, but I loved seeing how all of the jury members tried manipulating things to make certain events go their way. The multiple POVs made this even more intense and had me glued to this book to figure it all out. I will say that you do need to suspend your disbelief with how some things go, but it was still very entertaining. I do wish we got more of the trial and news segments, because I feel like it could’ve added to the tension of the story.
The twists and reveals at the end were interesting, but seemed a bit far-fetched at the same time. That being said, I did have a great time reading This Jury Is Guilty and I hope Laurie gives us more books in the future! This was a great debut.

If Laurie Blake was capable of writing a story like this for her debut, I can’t wait to see where her writing journey takes us. Hopefully we get more locked-room thrillers! Do you have any locked-room thrillers to recommend? I would love to read some more. Let me know in the comments. I’d love to hear from you!


